photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Karen Stuebing | all galleries >> Photo A Day and Challenges - 2012 >> March 2012 - What I Saw Today > Brush Creek Drive By Snapshot
previous | next
18-MAR-2012 Karen Stuebing

Brush Creek Drive By Snapshot

West Virginia

I did not use the minimum aperture on this photo. Next to it. f22. Shutter speed would have been a little too slow if I used f32 to shoot hand held.

It is a misconception that stopping down increases clarity. It doesn't. As Allen Hopkins put it, the best way to get a photo is "f8 and be there." I usually never shoot above f16 or f22 and that's with medium format. With digital, I'm comfortable between f5/6 and f8 and I have a large sensor.

When you reduce the aperture size, diffraction will start and image quality will be reduced.

Those of us who are very old and started with film know this. You control your exposure by using different speed films. But then we used to think it was fun to shoot people posed so it looked like a tree was growing out of their head. We weren't Ansel Adams. :)

Btw, I am not putting down the challenge. It was fun to actually test this and see what kind of image the Mamiya would get at f22 since I rarely use it. f22 not the Mamiya.

Other people "stopping down" can be seen here.

Mamiya RB67 ,Mamiya Sekor 65mm K/L
1/60s f/22.0 iso100 full exif

other sizes: small medium original auto
comment
Jeff Real07-Apr-2012 00:10
A rich and beautiful image. Extra special composition ~V~
Tom LeRoy21-Mar-2012 18:37
Interesting discussion and info from you on the stopping down. You still have lots of detail in this nice scene ... It's the medium format can do it all! V.
Cindi Smith21-Mar-2012 02:53
A beautiful image for sure!
LynnH21-Mar-2012 01:25
Nice work Karen. Loads of depth and details. Nice even color and light V
Barbara Heide20-Mar-2012 22:59
classical!
Matylda Lempel-Chareza Photography20-Mar-2012 15:36
excellent whit f22,vote
Carl Carbone20-Mar-2012 01:13
Very interesting. I'm impressed by many that shoot with wider apertures and get fantastic focal length. I always seem to get very shallow DOF. Lovely shot too!
carol j. phipps19-Mar-2012 22:49
Outstanding drive-by!
Mairéad19-Mar-2012 20:59
A most attractive scene with the light catching the tree trunks. And interesting info as well.
Frank Brault19-Mar-2012 20:29
I agree that the diffraction is obvious, but this is still a lovely image due to the fine composition and lovely colors. Deep depth of field, but the diffraction partially offsets that. V
J. Scott Coile19-Mar-2012 19:26
Very depth.
Carl and Racine Erland19-Mar-2012 17:28
Great composition and colour...interesting info, thanks! - Racine
laine19-Mar-2012 16:32
It's a great handheld shot and so are the comments. As for the scene, it's quite breathtaking, Karen.
Simon Chandler19-Mar-2012 15:57
Beautiful composition with good dof and nice mood. Good info. v
Mike H.19-Mar-2012 05:39
I like this scene too; pretty good for a drive-by and the challenge restriction!
What you said in comment was interesting, and coincidentally, my own M.O.
Bryan Murahashi19-Mar-2012 05:25
Beautiful scene with this rushing river. V
borisalex19-Mar-2012 05:24
Diffraction is obvious! Love the light and dramatic colors1 v.
Guest 19-Mar-2012 02:49
That's a wonderful shot.
bill friedlander19-Mar-2012 02:35
I like the image with its nice stand of trees and gentle rapids. Thanks for that bit of information. I forget to check my settings most of the time so my EXIFs might not make sense to many. V
Jean D19-Mar-2012 02:18
A beautiful scene and well composed, Karen. ~V
janescottcumming19-Mar-2012 01:23
An attractive scene! I think you got a great shot. Lots of good information. V
Jola Dziubinska19-Mar-2012 00:04
Very nice composition of this spring scenery. V.
John King18-Mar-2012 23:56
It looks like a lovely day and this is an excellent image of this splendid scene with the water gently cascading down the stepped shelf formations of the river bed. V
Sheila18-Mar-2012 23:42
Great detail for a drive by shot! Lovely sky you have there too.
christopheru18-Mar-2012 23:41
Looks very good to me Karen.
Walter Otto Koenig18-Mar-2012 23:04
My image for the challenge was taken with a 10.5mm f/2.8 fisheye at f/22. Normally I would never shoot at that aperture with that lens, as a matter of fact it was the first time I did. I usually try to shoot at the "sweet spot" of lenses, or fairly wide open. So this was an interesting challenge for me. To be honest with the fisheye, I can't really tell the difference between f/8 and f/22. I suppose I should have used a different lens, perhaps a prime. I do agree with your comments though. A fine looking image by the way. "V"
Alan K18-Mar-2012 21:46
I don't do the challenges; I find them a little too restricting but I can guess what this one was. I found your commentary on this one most interesting, though I have to admit that with my 40D I've rarely noticed too many issues with diffraction. (I often shoot the same scene at various f/ stops just to see how it looks.) But then again I rarely go smaller than f/16 either unless I'm looking for as long an exposure as I can get. (Not for any particular reason other than I've seldom seen the need to.)
As for this one, I do like the composition; the river seeming to carve through the trees like that, with the trees that are leaning over it making almost an archway.
Range View 18-Mar-2012 21:26
Splendid shot very well taken, along with interesting comments. V.
David.
larose forest photos18-Mar-2012 21:23
I wish I knew my way around a camera as well as you do. I am learning from reading your various posts. I love this scene, by the way. It has a strong sense of winter departing. V
Stephanie18-Mar-2012 20:59
A beautiful view up the river! Nicely composed too! V :)
Guest 18-Mar-2012 20:58
I love this scene.
Coleen Perilloux Landry18-Mar-2012 20:44
You surely know your stuff..