photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Twenty Two: Black and white travel photography – making less into more > Billboard, Houston Street, New York City, 2006
previous | next
07-AUG-2006

Billboard, Houston Street, New York City, 2006

The face shouting at us through a mass of trees comes from a huge black and white billboard. The leaves, photographed with back lighting, were black. The only color in the scene was a bit of green translucence on the edges of some of the leaves – color that added nothing to the image. When I converted it to black and white, the image became unified and coherent. The shout becomes even more surreal when the reality of color yields to the abstraction of black and white.

Leica D-Lux 2
1/200s f/4.9 at 25.2mm iso100 full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis30-Nov-2006 20:24
Thanks, Chris. I have often noted that color is more real than black and white. But this subject is almost surreal. The reality here is actually the monochromatic nature of the subject itself. And so I made it in black and white to intensify that kind of reality.
Chris Sofopoulos30-Nov-2006 16:26
So strong and powerful image Phil! Only in monochrome could depict the things it wants to show!
Guest 13-Nov-2006 13:35
How brilliant!!
Phil Douglis03-Oct-2006 06:10
Most travel images are in color, Kev, because color is the language of reality, and reality is how we see, which is in color. However in this image, the reality is black and white. I saw little color with my eyes. And so I made the image work more effectively be removing all traces of it. Thanks for the observation.
Kaparu225-Sep-2006 21:36
I guess i hang 50-50 round black and white and colour travel images although interestingly i tend to choose more colour images for sharing on the Net. A very nice composition Phil - nice use of the natural framing of the poster and a good crop too .

best wishes Kev
Phil Douglis18-Aug-2006 06:57
Your positive response to this image was heartening, Ai Li -- I rarely make black and white images, because I regard color as central to the meaning of travel photography, which reflects reality, not fantasy. However now and then an image such as this comes along, and screams for conversion (pun intended!) It is working exactly as I had hoped. A harsh image with a very loud shout. I don't know if you've seen my black and white gallery yet, but in case you have not, you need to do so. Be sure to read my introduction, closely. It's athttp://www.pbase.com/pnd1/black_and_white
AL18-Aug-2006 05:56
I always enjoy b&w pictures, not that I simply like shooting them, but because of its abstracting power to express and define a different set of meaning, emotion and mood. I often toss and try to decide on the version, color or b&w, which is less conflicting or distracting, which is telling a stronger story. It may be a matter of preference. B&W may be less real, but it sometimes makes me look and think more carefully and deeper. In this case, I looked straight at the poster lady and her shout. The leaves were no longer a distraction, in fact they helped to zoom my attention to the main subject. They also, due to lack of color, became harsher, making her shout even more forceful. Interesting impact.
Phil Douglis17-Aug-2006 21:52
Thanks, Jen, for coming to this photograph. You are right -- the abstracting force of black and white turns the leaves from green foliage to black barrier, stressing the energy needed to be heard beyond that barrier. As for voices being heard here in America, anyone can speak his or her piece. But yes, we sometimes have to raise our voices to be heard because there are so many other voices competing for attention.
Jennifer Zhou17-Aug-2006 15:31
I love it Phil.. Black and white makes the tree rather a symbol of barrier, block people away from each other. I wonder in a free speech nation like America, do people sometimes couldn't get their voices to be heard and they have to shout it out... I am glad that you find a way to listen...
Phil Douglis13-Aug-2006 22:32
Yes, I hear it too -- the shout could well be a call for conversation. It could also be a demand to buy jeans -- the ad is from The Gap.
Tim May13-Aug-2006 20:46
I see this related to your other image "Madison Square" (http://www.pbase.com/pnd1/image/65087506 ) as a follow up - I hear her shouting, "Save the trees!"
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment