photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Fifteen: Making travel portraits that define personality and character. > Fast Food, St. Malo, France, 2004
previous | next
30-AUG-2004

Fast Food, St. Malo, France, 2004

Brittany is famed for its crepes, and this fellow makes and sells them from an open shop in the middle of town. And if you don't want crepes, he will be glad to make you a pizza or sell you an ice cream cone. I shot him as he worked for about fifteen minutes or so. My pictures were describing what he was doing, and whom he was serving, but they did not say very much about him as a person. Finally he looked up from his work at me, just long enough for me to make this environmental portrait. He is posing for my camera, but in his own way, and for his own reasons. In one hand, he holds a knife above the crepes he is making. His other hand grasps the plastic shield that defines his work area. He never said a word to me. But his expression did. He seemed pleased, almost proud, that someone would even want to make a photograph of him. I think self-confidence, enthusiasm, and patience mark his presence as well. But what really makes this travel portrait tell its story is the context brought to it by his surroundings. The menu behind him is critical. It defines the scope of his business, as well as telling us where this picture was made. The compact nature of his work area tells us more about what he does and how he does it. His little counter is a one-man operation, and every inch of working space is put to use. The utensils in his jars rhythmically repeat the diagonal thrust of his arm, linking the work to the man. I feel that this portrait tells us not only what he does, and what he looks like, but who he is. And that is the primary purpose of any portrait. How do you feel about this image? I hope you will be willing to leave your own comments, questions, and criticisms below, and I’ll be glad to respond. Many thanks.

Canon PowerShot G5
1/50s f/2.8 at 15.8mm full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis05-May-2007 18:37
I am sure that you will get an argument from Anna Yu on this point, Azlin. I have never tasted it, so I can't verify either yours or Anna's point of view.
Azlin Ahmad05-May-2007 12:37
Nutella is the greatest invention since sliced bread! And what I see here is a man who seems to be proud and happy with his work - bring on the calories! :-)
Phil Douglis01-Jan-2005 22:37
Hi, Guzz, Glad you like this shot. If this image has triggered such thoughts in your mind, it is doing its job as an expressive photo. As for looking at me or my camera, I would have to say both. Camera and photographer are inseparable.
Guest 01-Jan-2005 14:23
Hey Phil, another comment from a french crepe's amateur. ;)

I really like this picture (and your work, have to admit). I can imagine him being proud for the next minutes (maybe hours) after the shot, maybe telling his wife later on :"hey, a guy took a picture of me today!". Just a question : was he looking at the camera or at you?

Keep on going.
Phil Douglis08-Nov-2004 04:49
Oh, Claudio, is Anna going to love this comment. First the Americans, then the French, and now the Italian Canadians all vote for Nutella, leaving our Swedish representative the odd lady out.

And yes this is a spontaneously posed portrait -- a hybrid as you would call it. He has indeed paused for a moment to stand back and let us know that he is proud of his little stand, Nutella and all.

Thanks for chipping in, friend Claudio!
Claudio Gatti08-Nov-2004 03:59
Hi Phil,

OK since there seems to be some debate, I'll give you also an Italian opinion, given that Nutella is one of our national treasures ;-): it's delicious in so many different ways. On crepes as you have captured here, but also on waffles. Our Canadian version for Sunday brunch, is waffles with Nutella and fresh fruits and berries, topped with maple syrup.. can't do it too often, but it's delicious ;-)

I also get a hybrid feeling in between a posed and a candid. I can see that Captain Mimi is going about his business and just took a glance at you, but I guess that's the effect of he looking at us, and the sensation of a little pause in his rhythmic routine. I like how you captured the one-man operation here, especially the sense of limited space. That's one of the essence of this type of French crepes place you are comunicating us that idea loud and clear.

Claudio
Phil Douglis01-Nov-2004 17:33
At long last, a French opinion of Nutella. (I can't wait to tell Anna!) Vive la France, indeed. Thanks, Jim, for this and all of your insightful comments.
Phil
Jim Chiesa01-Nov-2004 10:29
My boys LOVE homemade crepes with a ton of Nutella ! Thanks for this representative of these pleasant moments that one can see over here. "Vive la France" !
Phil Douglis09-Oct-2004 00:31
Glad you can look past the Nutella and get to the core of the image,Carol.
Carol E Sandgren05-Oct-2004 19:24
Oh God! Crepes and nutella...oh so bad but oh so good! The baker does look quite proud of his craft. I like the straightforward look in his eye to your camera.
Phil Douglis26-Sep-2004 05:20
Glad to know it, Ray. Just don't tell Anna Yu!

Phil
Guest 26-Sep-2004 03:41
Nutella rocks! I could probably live off it. :)
Phil Douglis26-Sep-2004 00:31
I love debates about my pictures, Bruce. Even if they are about peanut butter. Like this fellow, debates over the merits of my images stir the pot and get people thinking about ideas, and that is exactly why I have put together this cyberbook.
Phil
Guest 25-Sep-2004 18:30
A pause in the workflow, he smiles, conveying pride in his work and a sense of welcome. Little did he know that he would become a matter of debate! Just for the record - I like Nutella and, being from the US, I'm not overexposed to its label. Perhaps this helps to explain the reaction of Anna - what if this was an American vendor and he had a container of Skippy peanut butter?
Phil Douglis21-Sep-2004 17:15
Wonderful comment, Robin. Glad to see differences of opinion begin to explode here in the old cyberbook. You will never change Anna's mind, of course. She hates Nutella with a passion. You are right about this as a working shot. He just looked up at me very briefly, and then got back to business. As for the "hybrid,' comment, that's a great way to put it. It is not a candid shot. He knows he is having his picture taken. But he is not really posing, either. He just looked at me and reacted to what I was doing.

I never, ever ask people to pose in a certain way for me. If they wish to look into my camera, it will be on their terms, not mine. I want my portraits to be spontaneous, natural, never forced or stiff or silly. I am passionately opposed to those faked poses -- you can always sense when people have been asked to behave in a certain way for a picture. Beware of smirks, crossed arms, or pointing fingers. The are little more than pretense.

Thanks, Robin, for your comment -- you validate my intentions here.
robin statfeld21-Sep-2004 13:29
Ah but he IS working. His hand shows that he is about to make his next creation. The empty Nutella jar shows that he has already made some hungry people happy, and the full jar shows that he is about to satisfy some more. His expression, caught somewhat offguard as you describe Phil, is one of pride in his work.
I do see this photo as somewhat of a "hybrid" - a cross between a totally candid shot and a posed portrait - and an effective one at that. But I would have been interested to see his stance and expression had you specifically asked him to pose. Would he have held up his spatula and pointed to the menu with a silly face? Would he have crossed his arms confidently in front of his work area?... And do you think any of these poses would be more or less effective than the expression that you did catch?
Oh, and may I respectfully disagree... to me, Nutella is food of the gods : )
Phil Douglis20-Sep-2004 18:51
Fascinating, Anna. You see the horrible Nutella. You would have liked to have seen him working. For me, the Nutella was context only, one of his tools. And by looking at the camera, he looks at all of us, as if to welcome us into his little world. The eye contact here makes this a portrait, Anna. I made lots of pictures of him working, but they did not say anything about who he was to me. This did.
Anna Yu20-Sep-2004 14:40
The first thing that caught my eye here is that huge jar of horrible Nutella. I really hate Nutella. I got to thinking that an environmental portrait needs a wide-angle lens. I didn't analyse anymore than that here. I know you prefer people to look straight into the camera, but I would have liked to see him at work.
Phil Douglis18-Sep-2004 03:42
I don't know. I didn't taste them. But the good folk of St. Malo certainly enjoyed them!
Lara S18-Sep-2004 03:20
Comme c'est bon, les crepes.
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment