photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Sixteen: Story-telling street photography > Restauradores Station, Lisbon, Portugal, 2004
previous | next
04-SEP-2004

Restauradores Station, Lisbon, Portugal, 2004

I try to keep my street photography as simple as possible, making sure that everything in the frame helps the picture work. I spent over a half hour working on this shot, shooting people passing through and by the great Moorish-style horseshoe arches which serve as the main entrance to Lisbon’s central commuter station. My goal was to use the doors as context, offering the viewer a sense of place. The spacing, attitude and body language of the passersby would tell my story, but I had no idea what my finished picture would look like beforehand. In street photography, you never do. I don’t control the image. I am an observer – I may build the stage, but the actors must play their own roles. Most of my early shots were just of people walking by – literal, cluttered snapshots. There were far too many people in the frame as well, so I had to wait until the crowds thinned out and the picture simplified itself.

I noticed the woman at left early on – she was not going anywhere. She was either waiting for someone, or she was a person in need of funds, because she often stopped to talk to people, most of whom walked right past her. She became my focal point and as the crowds gradually thinned out, fewer and fewer people engaged her in conversation. Folding her arms in on herself, she eventually aligned herself squarely in front of one of the two doors. When the man at right walked into my frame, I timed my shutter release to align him in front of the other door to create a study in contrasts. The two doors are identical mirrors of each other, but the two people are about as far apart in mood and manner as two people can be. She looks past him and he looks past her. She stands still and he is moving. He is big and she is small. There is an obvious difference in both gender and race as well. They do not acknowledge each other, and they take their environment for granted. They might as well be on different planets, yet these massive decorative doors, representing another era, link them forever within a moment of present time.

This is one of those images that leave the point of the story to each viewer to figure out. Some of you may see different things going on here than I did, and that is what street photography is all about. Effective street photography is not always not tidy or definitive. This image asks questions of the viewer, and each of you must answer for yourself. What does this picture express to you? Does it work? If so, why, and if not, why not? Please post your comments, pro or con.

Canon PowerShot G5
1/125s f/4.0 at 8.0mm hide exif
Full EXIF Info
Date/Time04-Sep-2004 22:38:08
MakeCanon
ModelPowerShot G5
Flash UsedNo
Focal Length8 mm
Exposure Time1/125 sec
Aperturef/4
ISO Equivalent
Exposure Bias
White Balance (-1)
Metering Modemulti spot (3)
JPEG Quality (6)
Exposure Program
Focus Distance

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis12-Oct-2004 03:40
I like your "same only different" concept. It never occurred to while I was shooting this, but in retrospect, why not?
Glad it works for you, Carol. Coming from someone with your eye for design and color, it's high praise indeed.
Carol E Sandgren12-Oct-2004 02:57
It works for me. "They're the same only different." Same in that they are both human beings who deserve all the same rights and priveliges. Both have the capacity to communicate, but they choose not to. They even appear before twin identical arched doors. Different in that one may be coming and one may be going. Different in that they may be in different social classes, speak different languages and live in different styles. I do think this photograph points this out very clearly, Phil. Funny, I didn't even notice the manhole cover in the pavement.
Guest 07-Oct-2004 14:38
Very well done!
Phil Douglis26-Sep-2004 21:19
Thanks, Pedro, for this information. I will correct all of my references to Rossio Station and change it to Restauradores Staton. I certainly did love Lisbon. I hope you can sense this in my pictures.
Phil
Guest 26-Sep-2004 16:20
Great picture Phil !

Verynice picture of Lisbon, yes I'm ffrom Portugal and I have to make a correction this is not Rossio Station it's Restauradores Station.
Rossio is juat aside by side with Restauradores ...In Rossio you have Metro Station and this is the Train station at Restauradores.
Very nice photo ! Did you love Lisbon of curse, am I right ?

Regards from Pedro.
From Setúbal (40 km away from Lisbon) - Portugal.
Phil Douglis17-Sep-2004 22:44
And that, dear Vanessa, is my fault. I should have looked at the damned pavement while making this shot but was concentrating so hard on the people that I never saw the camouflaged manhole cover, and now I've set you off to your own fantasies of Purgatory and Hades. I think the great Moorish doors of Rossio Station might have had something to do with this as well. They have an exotic quality to them that lifts this picture out of the normal world and puts it on a fantasy level to begin with. If this was just any old street, I am not sure you would be thinking of trapdoors to hell. As for you creating another story within my story, I have no problem with that at all -- as long as it has something to do with the point of my story. And yours does. The guy is about to be at least symbolically punished for ignoring the helpless girl. So I would say this image works for you, right? If so, that's why I made it.
Vanessa 17-Sep-2004 22:24
I find the manhole to be distracting only because I've created another story within this story. The man is being punished for not noticing the helpless girl. Because of his disregard for his fellow man (or woman), the door to Hades is opened beneath his feet.

How's that for creating a story?
Phil Douglis17-Sep-2004 22:08
Thanks, Vanessa for bringing up Doisneau in the same breath as this picture. I am flattered by the comparision, and it tells me that this picture is a successful street shot, because he was a master street photographer. You got my point about two ships passing in the night here. And I never saw the manhole cover (trap door?) until you mentioned. Do you think is a distraction, or can it be thought of as part of the story?

P.
Guest 17-Sep-2004 21:58
Phil,

When I viewed this image I was immediately reminded of a picture Robert Doisneau made of a cop on the streets of Paris. Do you know which one I'm talking about?

I think this image works. Effective illustration of contrast between the two subjects. It is clear that both of these people are oblivious to the other and to the world for that matter.

On a side note - I keep looking at the guy walking and expecting the trap door to be released below his feet!
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment