photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Dave Berry | all galleries >> Galleries >> Vietnam War '67 - '68 > Battle of Ong Thanh memorial service
previous | next

Battle of Ong Thanh memorial service

The reading of the names. Although the final toll of KIA/Died of Wounds/MIA (Body Not Recovered) was at least 60, only 38 names were read. There was a lot of confusion about who was wounded and in hospitals throughout the area. Getting our wounded out of the jungle, however we could, was the priority as the battle ended. There was no way of keeping track of their disposition. We were ordered to withdraw from the ambush site as darkness fell, and couldn't recover the bodies until the next morning. It took days to identify all of the bodies. I hate to be cynical, but there was also evidence that the Division Command deliberately withheld names in order to deceive the media, and the public, about the number of casualties. When books were finally written about the battle in the early 2000s, research found that the Division Commander, MG Hay, and some members of Westmoreland's staff agreed to hold down the number of decorations awarded in order to reduce publicity and public outcry - action which was disrespectful to the horrendous price that our soldiers paid for tactical errors on the part of the leadership. Ironically, and shamefully wrong, MG Hay himself was awarded, and accepted, a Silver Star Medal for valor in the battle, in which he did not participate.

On the left of the image is the newly-arrived Battalion Commander, Major Louis Menetrey (quickly promoted to LTC), who replaced LTC Terry Allen Jr., killed in the battle. Behind the speaker is the Chaplain. Major Menetrey rose in rank to the highest levels, retiring many years later as General (4-star). He was an outstanding leader.

This series of images are screen shots from CBS film coverage of the memorial service.


other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Anthony Seahorn 22-Aug-2021 22:49
Clark Welch was my friend and fellow officer with the Black Lions, 1st Infantry Division. He was a true leader and hero on that fateful day. His memorial at Arlington should read MOH.
john durham 20-Nov-2017 17:30
What a travesty that unearned awards were made while those who fought and suffered so valiantly have not been shown the respect and thanks they deserve. Awarding proper medals could at least show some respect to the families of the lost and to the surviving soldiers, some of whom still suffer from this tragic "mistake". I'm still saddened that the DSC for Clark Welch wasn't the MOH. Lord knows, plenty of witnesses and efforts were made to correct that during his life time.

Thank you for keeping the story alive so it can be totally revealed for future generations that I pray will understand the cost, the responsibility, and the gratitude this nation owes men like these.

Respectfully, John Durham (brother of 2nd Lt HB "Pinky" Durham, Jr, KIA 10/17)
Tom Briggs07-Feb-2017 18:00
Memories ... not always good ones
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment