photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
OLLI | all galleries >> 2015_archive >> april_2015 >> critique_april_2015 > Reflections
previous | next
09-OCT-2014

Reflections


other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
George Bradshaw 15-Apr-2015 20:58
I almost walked away from taking this photo: my intent was to photograph the interior of a small restored house from the vantage of it's front yard through a window. After several unsuccessful attempts, I finally noticed that the reflections had their own intrigue.

[This photograph was taken in October 2014 for an NVCC photography course for which the following description was written and is here modified for the OPC.]

Grandmother’s House

What “situation” have we here? A room in an old house, a window suspended in space, a treed lawn inside the room? Being reminiscent of Twilight Zone themes, perhaps Rod Serling can straighten out this situation.

Photograph was taken at the Blenheim House, a refurbished Civil War-era house and museum in Fairfax City. The subject is “Grandmother’s House” on the Blenheim grounds, and it has both technical interest and artistic value, though I feel its interest is related primarily to the technical aspect. The photograph was taken from outside the house with the left side of the camera’s hooded lens touching a pane of the house's right front window. The camera is focused upon boxes that can be seen in a back room through a door. The resulting image contains five sub-images at different distances, one of which is out of focus despite the f/11 aperture:

1. The wall of the room with door through which is the back room.
2. The adjacent side wall with only the side window visible, not the wall itself.
3. The side window’s outside view.
4. The reflection in the front window of a) a gravel path, b) a lawn, and c) a treed area, including a well-house a good 200 feet behind the camera.
5. The lens hood and the dirt spots on the front window, both of which are out of focus.

Note that the lens hood provides shade so the interior of the house can be seen.
This collage also has artistic value in that the multiple images are juxtaposed in a way that never would have existed during the house’s residential use years ago. The view from the residence at its original location (near the Fairfax City Starbuck’s in the shopping center with the Ace Hardware) would have been of the commerce taking place near Fairfax “Courthouse” as the area was called in the early 19th century. Grandmother would have seen agricultural wagons loaded with tobacco, other wagons loaded with milk containers, perhaps even cattle being driven along the road. Across the rain-muddied, animal-bespotted street was a hotel. Just behind the house, however, would have been a working farm, though our contemporary perception of pristine farming operations would not have been satisfied. As Susan Sontag wrote: “Humankind lingers unregenerately in Plato’s cave, still reveling, its age-old habit, in mere images of the truth.” [Sontag, Susan. 1973. On Photography. New York: Picador.]
© Bradshaw 2014
Tom Hady 09-Apr-2015 23:49
Using a reflection from a window glass, which I suspect this is, was a creative idea. For me, the right hand half adds very little. I think the picture would be stronger with just the right had part. The window floating in the scene adds a "what in the world is going on?" theme that's rather interesting.--TFH
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment