photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Cecilia Lim | all galleries >> travel >> malaysia > Islam in Malaysia
previous | next
3 September 2007 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Islam in Malaysia

The Kampung Baru Mosque and its surroundings was Ground Zero during the worst racial riot in the history of Malaysia of malays against the chinese. Many chinese were killed, and even thousands more were left injured & homeless. This riot happened in 1969 and remains to this day a very sensitive, embarrasing and dark event in the history of Malaysians. The barb wire to me represents the pain of this tumultuous period, and also the growing oppression suffered by all races (malays included) post 1969 due to the stronghold of Islam in the country, which is the dominant religion. From what I can see, the interpretation of Islam today by muslim spiritual leaders and politicians, encourages more and more rules & regulations to be imposed on the everyday lives of their fellow muslims. Non-muslims have also been forced unfairly to adopt islamic ways at times. This control I feel has created a very oppressed and stifled society. The muslim malays who are the predominant race in politics have also created policies that promote malay supremecy and disadvantage other races. The minority races such as the ethnic chinese and indians do not have equal rights and as long as these acts of discrimination continue, Malaysians will never be truly free.

Also see Tim's almost identical image at http://www.pbase.com/mityam/image/87464021.


other sizes: small medium original auto
comment | share
Cecilia Lim11-Jul-2008 20:44
Thanks Tim & Phil for your wonderfully thoughtful comments here. We can clearly see how a change in focus affects meaning, and how important selective focus is as a tool in our story-telling. And yes, much of our experiences shape our views and opinions, which ultimately affects how we choose to express ourselves in photography. Tim, your image about Islam and Malaysia being "not far separated" is infact spot-on. Islam and government in Malaysia are constitutionally inseparable, and my image speaks of my views about that.

Thanks for echoing my comment on your "Ground Zero" image here too, Phil. Both our images remind us that there are two sides to every story and that when we go too far in imposing our values on others, how tragic that outcome can be.
Phil Douglis10-Jul-2008 22:27
I read your caption once again and Tim's response to this image and his references to his own. Your dialogue and your images show us how just a subtle shift in focus can profoundly change meaning. The attack of Muslim extremists upon our own country on September 11, 2001, killing thousands, triggering a war that has killed many more thousands and altering life for all of us, everywhere, and my image of ground zero (http://www.pbase.com/image/65087519 ) also draws on the juxtaposition of a building and barbed wire for its meaning. I re-read your comment on that image, made two years ago, and was struck by your phrase "it makes us question our values, and the price we are prepared to pay to attain them." It could just as well be said for this image, Celia.
Tim May09-Jul-2008 00:39
Wow - what a caption! Thank you for linking to my image. It is interesting to me how the images seem almost identical yet they are really very different because of focus. In my image the barbed wire is soft and the flag and dome are sharp. I meant to focus on the fact that Malaysia is an Islamic nation and flag and mosque are not far separated. Your image focuses on the results of that tie. I might add that I have images with the barbed wire in focus. Our images come from us and how we experience the world. Even though we are friends, we have very different world experiences. This image and mine show that fact.