photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Twenty Nine: The Layered Image – accumulating meaning > The Vision, Santa Fe, New Mexico, 2005
previous | next
15-JUL-2005

The Vision, Santa Fe, New Mexico, 2005

I was struck by the incongruity of this mural – a surrealistic halo-wrapped Virgin Mary rising from a barren desert amidst a pile of enormous flowers. And then I saw the barred window cut into the sky of the mural. Meanwhile, that is real earth at the base of the mural, supporting a bush, incongruously growing in front of the painting. One might wonder which came first, the bush or the painting? This foreground layer provides the only reality in the image, yet it miraculously merges into the mural – the middleground subject layer -- as if it was a vision created by the Virgin Mary herself. The barred window, along with the curved sliver of sky overhead, reveals the entire mural as painted on the wall of a building, which in turn creates a background layer. It is fascinating – we can look at the building as either a structure or as a mural. In this image, these middleground and background layers can change roles, depending upon how you choose to look at them.

Canon PowerShot G6
1/1250s f/5.0 at 7.2mm full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis17-Aug-2005 00:10
Thanks so much, Tim, for adding this context to this image. I knew nothing of this story when I made this image. I have little interest in or knowledge of theological matters, but as a travel photographer I often find myself interpreting subjects created by or for those that do. I come to each of these images with an open mind. I look for symbolic meaning, and I found it here within the incongruities present in this image. Now you give reasons why many of these symbols are present. And the meaning of this image is thereby altered accordingly.
Tim May16-Aug-2005 23:48
Here is a retelling of part of the Virgin of Guadalupe story:
"Among their first converts was a man baptized with the Christian name Juan Diego. On the chilly morning of December 9, 1531, Juan Diego crossed the barren hill called Tepeyac to attend Mass. He was brought to a sudden halt by a blinding light and the sound of unearthly music. Before him appeared an astounding vision--a beautiful dark-skinned woman who, calling the Indian "my son," declared herself to be the Virgin Mary, the mother of Jesus Christ. She told Juan Diego it was her desire to have a church built on Tepeyac hill, and asked him to relay that message to Bishop Juan de Zumarraga.

It was no easy task for the humble Indian to be granted an audience with the top prelate, but the persistent Juan Diego was finally admitted. The incredulous Bishop demanded that he be provided with some proof of the unlikely encounter. Confused and fearful, Juan Diego avoided Tepeyac for several days, but on December 12, while rushing to find a priest to attend a seriously ill uncle, he took a short cut across the hill. The Virgin once again appeared and Juan Diego told her of the Bishop's request. The Virgin instructed him to pick roses from the usually sere and desolate hill and deliver them to Zumarraga as the sign.

Juan Diego gathered up the miraculous blossoms in his mantle and hurried off to complete his mission. Once again before the Bishop, he let the roses spill out before him. To the wonder of all assembled, a perfect image of La Virgen Morena (the Dark Virgin) was revealed emblazoned on Juan Diego's cloak.

While not religious this is one of my favorite stories because it speaks of the lowly breaking through to the powerful.
Your image captures well the sense of place where the miracle seems to have happened.
Phil Douglis26-Jul-2005 18:15
People said Georgia O'Keefe's flowers were sexually explicit, too, Marek. Fitting then, that this mural be in Santa Fe, the town so closely associated with O'Keefe. One of the things that attracted me to this scene was the ambiguity of the symbols here. The bush (I'll leave GWB out of it for now) is a symbol of nature and growth, and as you say, it has biblical overtones as well. And that is what makes it such an incongruous fit here -- the juxtaposition of the barren desert, the starkness of the mural, the Madonna miraculously rising out of the foliage, are all clashing here in a surreal blend of reality and fantasy. As for your suggestion of that "religion as a prison" metaphor, that is a function of the theological context each viewer brings to it. If you are religious, you will look right past that metaphor. But if you find theology to be confining or pressuring, it may be a perfect metaphor. I will let the image speak for itself, and each viewer can address it in their own way. Thanks, Marek, for this thought provoking commentary.
Guest 26-Jul-2005 11:04
I find this image quite amusing, as it's another take on the 'Burning Bush' ;-) Also it has a subtle message of the prison-like nature of religion (as far as I'm concerned). Overall, it would make a great greeting card for GWB. Perhaps you should offer it... I also find the quite sexual interpretation of the roses combined with the 'fig-leaf' bush entertainingly blasphemous... In fact, the entire image is quite erotic really if you look at it as shapes...
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment