photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Frank Nadeau Photos | profile | all galleries >> Testing photography >> Canon 5D Mark II + CAnon 14mm II L USM VS Sony A900 + Tamron SP 14mm tree view | thumbnails | slideshow

Canon 5D Mark II + CAnon 14mm II L USM VS Sony A900 + Tamron SP 14mm

This is a brief challenge a difference aperture with Same ISO setting and light meeter.

Canon 5D Mark II + CAnon 14mm II L USM VS Sony A900 + Tamron SP 14mm

Picture in both camera took in RAW at ISO 200, Imported in Lightroom, and Saved in JPEG at 70% + low sharpening option.
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-4000 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-4000 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-4000 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-4000 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-4000 sec at Ÿ - 3.2.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-4000 sec at Ÿ - 3.2.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-2500 sec at Ÿ - 3.2.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-2500 sec at Ÿ - 3.2.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-2500 sec at Ÿ - 4.0.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-2500 sec at Ÿ - 4.0.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-2000 sec at Ÿ - 4.0.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-2000 sec at Ÿ - 4.0.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-1250 sec at Ÿ - 5.6.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-1250 sec at Ÿ - 5.6.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-1000 sec at Ÿ - 5.6.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-1000 sec at Ÿ - 5.6.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-640 sec at Ÿ - 7.1.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-640 sec at Ÿ - 7.1.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-640 sec at Ÿ - 7.1.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-640 sec at Ÿ - 7.1.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-640 sec at Ÿ - 8.0.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-640 sec at Ÿ - 8.0.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-500 sec at Ÿ - 8.0.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-500 sec at Ÿ - 8.0.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-320 sec at Ÿ - 10.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-320 sec at Ÿ - 10.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-320 sec at Ÿ - 10.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-320 sec at Ÿ - 10.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-200 sec at Ÿ - 13.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-200 sec at Ÿ - 13.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-160 sec at Ÿ - 13.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-160 sec at Ÿ - 13.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-160 sec at Ÿ - 16.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-160 sec at Ÿ - 16.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-125 sec at Ÿ - 16.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-125 sec at Ÿ - 16.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-250 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-250 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-200 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-200 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-500 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-500 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-125 sec at ƒ - 11.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-125 sec at ƒ - 11.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-5000 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-5000 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-800 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-800 sec at Ÿ - 2.8.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-80 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg
Canon L II USM - 14 mm - 1-80 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg		 Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-40 sec at ƒ - 11.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-40 sec at ƒ - 11.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-125 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg
Tamron SP - 15 mm - 1-125 sec at Ÿ - 11.jpg

comment | share
GRLpGpAG 21-Jul-2020 16:38
20
GRLpGpAG 21-Jul-2020 16:38
20
GRLpGpAG 21-Jul-2020 16:38
20
GRLpGpAG 21-Jul-2020 16:38
20
Frank Nadeau Photos04-Apr-2009 22:54
yes the Tamron show strong vigneting compare to the Canon at large opening. And the Canon is constant for the sharpness from the center to corner compare to the tamron.

If you click on any picture, you have on the bottom the option to get the original, by clicking on the Original link.

Other option is clicking on the picture too, and adding "/original.jpg" at the end.

Regards,

Frank
Mal 04-Apr-2009 20:33
After looking at the photos again I believe there is more vinyetting in the Tamron lens at 2.8. The sky looks darker in the corners. Would you be kind enough to direct me to the full size photos ~6,000 x 4000 size. Thanks Mal
Mal 04-Apr-2009 20:28
These photos look identical at the magnifications you are giving i.e. thumbnail or 800 pixel size. An 800 pixel size photo - (most of the screen size) is the equivalent for resolution purposes to a 2 x 3 inch photo (based on 300 DPI for a print). In order for us to see any real differences we need the original jpeg at full size. Any camera can be used to take a photo used for a postage stamp - the differences is in the enlargements.
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment
click on thumbnails for full image