photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Stu | all galleries >> Daily Bowl of Stu >> November 2004 > Bury my heart
previous | next
Dundee Stu

Bury my heart

1 November 2004

195.
Back in 1988 I was quite friendly with a couple who were fascinated with the history of the Native Americans. At that time, I suppose my view of the Native Americans was that of most people brought up on a diet of Hollywood westerns in which the heroes were John Wayne and Gary Cooper. All that changed, though. This couple led the campaign to have the "Glasgow" Ghost Shirt returned to the Lakota Sioux. Through them, I became aware of the history of the Lakota, and even met a couple of their representatives who had travelled to Scotland to press for the shirt's return. The biggest impression, however, was made by the book they recommended I read: 'Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee', by Dee Brown. As a historian, I am very aware that history is written by the victors, and that the vanquished are often demonised. Brown's book, however, presents the case from the defeated people's point of view, and does so without bitterness or hatred. It is a deeply passionate recounting of the destruction of an entire culture, the virtual genocide of an entire people who defended themselves as best they could with the limited resources at their disposal. Brown tells us how the Native Americans, people who had initially welcomed the white settlers, were cheated and lied to as the 'whites' broke just about every treaty that had been made between the two peoples. It is essential reading for anyone who wishes to restore some balance to the history of the 'Wild West', and to see how these 'brave' pioneers escaped the repression and intolerance of the old Europe, only to practice it on the people that they dispossessed. The Native Americans lost their struggle back then, and they continue to pay the price today: they have higher infant mortality rates (15.3/000 as opposed to 8.7/000 for whites), shorter life expectancy, lower educational attainment and much lower earnings than the US average. On the eve of the most important election in US history, perhaps this is also something that people should be thinking on.

FujiFilm FinePix S7000Z
1/60s f/2.8 at 7.8mm iso200 full exif

other sizes: small medium original auto
share
Guest 28-Mar-2005 09:05
very interesting !
Vinay30-Nov-2004 03:03
One of my favourite books. Good choice. Another one is "In the Spirit of Crazy Horse" which is a modern day account of what's happening to the Indians. And thanks for all the comments on my galleries Stu.
Elaine (etfitz)02-Nov-2004 03:36
The perseverance of the Native Americans tribes have always fascinated me. It is wonderful that they are keeping their cultures alive.
Cheryl Hawkins01-Nov-2004 23:06
I read that book in 1972 while traveling from California to Michigan. It made a huge impact on me, confirming many of the ideals I already had. Definitely an eye-opening book, it helped strengthen my views on the treatment of indigenous people around the world.
Guest 01-Nov-2004 22:49
Nicely put Stu, but the world will be thinking about more important things come a few days - like how touch screen voting systems aren't too acurate (chads are so 4 years ago)!

My mum's right into family history and has even found an American Indian Kindness that's related.
Leo Charette01-Nov-2004 21:14
Yes, but it is not even on the radar for this election. That was a powerful book in my life.
Pedro Libório01-Nov-2004 21:12
quite interesting words and image Stu,
regards and have a nice trip!!!
jypsee01-Nov-2004 16:33
The US government broke EVERY treaty it ever made with Indians. Worse, the US government often went among the Indians here in the land they invaded and chose men that they could manipulate and deemed them the tribal leaders. Indeed, the notion of a "tribe" is a white notion. My people, the Potawatomi (Bode WaDemi) never had any sort of government that resembled a "tribe." Instead, we lived in big village groups with a head man and head woman and the village was the government. In summer villages came together to make gardens and to hunt together and to socialize (arrange marriages, trade, etc.) and in the winter, in order to exploit the resources more effectively, we broke into smaller family groups and moved into bark houses (wigwams). That all changed when the people who wanted to "treat" with Potawatomis decided that they couldn't deal with so many representatives, so they made one representative... that was the beginning of the destruction of the old ways. The Lakota people (and there are many groups of Lakotas, they are not just one culture) were the people whose cultures were still most intact or "left" when photographers began recording "vanishing Indians." So they are the representation of Indians that most non-Indians think of. And, since the dominant culture decides who or what is authentic, and because they like to deal only with simple ideas and not have to sort out over 500 nations, the Lakota are the "ideal" of what it is to be an Indian (I prefer that designation, it's the one I grew up with). There are plenty of good histories of Indians and whites here in the land we call Turtle Island; Dee Brown's was just a ground breaker in the 70's.
Here are some links to site devoted specifically to the mass murder of Mineconjou Lakotas at Wounded Knee:
http://www.bgsu.edu/departments/acs/1890s/woundedknee/WKIntro.html
This one is rife with pictures of the people who were killed and wounded and left in the cold for days before being buried in a mass grave which is now a memorial site on Wounded Knee Creek in South Dakota:
http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/today/dec29.html

Mary in Florida
Forest County Potawatomi Community
Dave (doon the road) 01-Nov-2004 15:35
Do a search on "Gambling Casinos on Indian land". Surprised? The Labour party is about to flood the UK with Merkan casinos. So I suppose the Indians are getting their own back.
Herb 01-Nov-2004 13:49
Interesting and true. Here in California and some other States the Gambling Casinos on Indian land have created a substantial shift in the power (Money) base of most Indian tribes. They have become a political power and there are quite a few Indian sponsored
initiatives on our ballots.
Dominic Kite01-Nov-2004 13:39
It's a shame that rich histories are maligned by the manner in which the media present the story. Nice to see some balance (and the book's just made it's way onto my amazon wish list!).
Gayle P. Clement01-Nov-2004 13:22
Some of my work in New Mexico has been with the native population there. I am fascinated by the strength of their culture and their determination to maintain their lifestyle and customs.
Guest 01-Nov-2004 10:52
Quite a big subject to discuss !
I've recorded a TV program yesterday evening about the fall of General Custer.
The story is told by indians, from the other side of the legend.
One has to listen to both side of the story to make up his mind.
I'm sure that will be an interesting program to watch...