photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Eight: Light and shadow shape meaning > Art school storage area, Shanghai, China 2004
previous | next
12-JUN-2004

Art school storage area, Shanghai, China 2004

Our tour group sent an hour or so visiting a neighborhood art school in Shanghai. My most memorable image from that adventure came from an unexpected place – a corner of a room used as a storage area for props and materials. Beautifully soft light was flowing into this corner from a nearby window. Whenever I make photographs, I try to look for the effective light first, and once I find it, I learn what subject matter it can illuminate for me. That was the case here. I had no intentions of photographing a floodlight, a few easels and a copy of large Greek sculpture. But when I saw how that window light was illuminating these things, I knew I had a chance to make an expressive image. I kept moving the camera until the floodlight and easels partially blocked the head, making it appear as if it was lurking there in the shadows. The head’s intrusion into the easels is incongruous and the light and shadow bathe the head in a soft glow. I focused and exposed on the brightest part of the picture with my spot meter – the curls on the big head. The rest of the image darkened accordingly, and I came away with this image of “art waiting in the wings for its moment.”

Leica Digilux 2
1/125s f/4.0 at 16.0mm iso100 full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis14-Oct-2005 03:13
If you read the comments below yours, Galina, you can see that you are not the first person to object to that lamp stand cutting through the face of the statue. Norah did not understand why it was there, either. I told Norah that I moved my camera deliberately to split the eye of the statue with it, creating tremendous tension. I wanted to trap statue in the junk, make it seem as if he was wishing to escape. I also told Norah that she was distracted because the placement of that lamp stand is definitely unconventional, and many photographers are used to thinking -- and seeing -- in conventional ways. The placement not only traps the statue, but it creates an incongruity that disturbs the viewer. Which if fine with me. If a viewer is disturbed, I might just trigger thoughts in his or her imagination, and that is what expressive photography is all about.

Be sure to read Ruth Hanson's comment as well, Galina. She finds my placement of the lamp stand adds to the feeling of entrapment. She says it make see us ourselves as the statue, thrown into a corner with a lot of junk, and having to fight our way out of it. She says it would be boring if the statue could just walk away without a struggle. In other words, what may be a distraction for you and for Norah became a trigger to Ruth's imagination. I don't expect everyone to agree with Ruth or with me. But I did want you to know my reasons for doing this and hopefully take something away with you that will help you to energize your own images with incongruous placement. Your comment is very valuable to me, Galina -- because once again, you help me to extend the lessons of this image to others.
Galina Stepanova13-Oct-2005 18:50
I heard many times, that photographers make changes when they photograph even wild scenery, like have special holders to hold flowers the way they want, not the natural way, On this pictures I am surely agree, light is soft and beautiful, and you photographed it very well, but... is not the lamp stand looks distracting, coming across the eye in the sculptures. Is not the idea of waiting would be completed with just sculpture and art stored together? You could move lamp, Phil, did you? Why you didn't do it?
Just a question.
Thank you!
Phil Douglis28-May-2005 00:10
Welcome back Norah. The light stand adds context to the eyes. It is at the core of this image. You want to see a different image, that's all. Which is fine. But the image you would prefer to see -- without the light stand slicing into the eye -- would not be my image any more. Please keep on commenting and learning as you go.
Guest 27-May-2005 19:55
hehe, phil, I come back. I still stand on my own viewpoint. Like the mood of this picture a lot. I like the light, the statue, his face, his expression, the crap around, but not the light stand. If you put it there intentionally, I would say it doesn't work for me. It is his eyes that express the sadness, but the light stand hinder such a convey.
Phil Douglis30-Apr-2005 21:52
You bring much of yourself into image, Ruth. You, too, often speak of coming to life and breaking free of all that junk that has been piled on top of you, so you know how he feels. I agree that the light stand, which apparently bothered Norah because she did not "read" the light stand as an unconventional, tension producing symbol of being hemmed in. She saw it only as a distracting stick. Of course you see yourself stuck in that corner. Everyone should! That was my point.
ruthemily30-Apr-2005 21:06
it looks like he is plotting. he's so intent on something, it's like any moment now he will come to life and break free of all that junk that's been piled on top of him. the light stand is needed to add to the feeling of him being trapped. it helps to personalise the statue and make us see ourselves in it, thrown in a dark corner along with a whole heap of junk that we have to fight our way free of. it would be boring if he could just get up and walk away without a struggle.
Phil Douglis27-Feb-2005 05:14
Thanks for like this image, Norah. The crap in the picture does add context for his sadness. Yet he lurks in the wings, waiting for his big moment. That "stick" as you call it is actually a light stand. And I carefully moved my camera to split his eye with it. Far from a distraction, that light stand forces him to look past it, to look for a way out of his mess. Can't you feel the tension there, Norah. Can't you just hear him saying "let me out of here, I want my big chance to model, to be a star again!" It's that light stand cutting through his face that is forcing the issue here. I think you are distracted because it is unconventional, and as a beginner you may be conditioned to seeing in conventional ways. As one of my cyberstudents, I intend to break you of that habit. I want to encourage you to see less conventionally. More incongruously. OK?

Still want to argue the point with me, Norah? If so, fire away. I can take it!

Phil
Guest 20-Feb-2005 01:59
I like this picture. The garbage besides the statue offer a scenario for his sadness. Yet I think it would be better if you move aside the stick in front of the statue, which is a little distracting.
Phil Douglis09-Oct-2004 00:23
At last, someone has commented on one of my favorite images from my trip to China. The light, along with the position of the head, tells the story. I'm glad you share its meaning with me, Carol.
Carol E Sandgren05-Oct-2004 19:05
My very first reaction to this photograph was one of sadness...for the copy of the Greek statue. Stuck in some dark dusty corner, abandoned. The interruption of the easels and the lampost seem to make it all the more forgotten...by some.
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment