photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment
Compass Marine How To | all galleries >> Welcome To >> Seacock Failure Testing > The Test Bench
previous | next
The Test Bench

The Test Bench

For a long while I have been meaning to test the strength of a ball valve threaded directly onto a thru-hull as many production builders do for seacock installations. These same builders very often display the ABYC logo proudly suggesting their vessels are built to meet the safety standards. In all fairness to the builders I suspect they believe these installations do or would meet the minimum safety standards but as I found out they certainly may not. We can't blame the builders for installing UL Marine parts and then not having them meet the minimum standards. You would assume the manufacturers would have tested these fittings for the application into which they are sold..

As I just found out the 3/4" Marine UL rated bronze valve threaded to a 3/4" Marine UL rated thru-hull fitting I purchased, does not meet ABYC H-27 Standards. It failed at just 404 pounds and I was an 1 3/8" below the "innermost" hard piping so had slightly less leverage than I would have had I been able to apply the load at the absolute innermost "hard piping". This 3/4" installation should have easily handled 500 pounds for 30 seconds if it were to meet the ABYC H-27 standard.

Does this test mean it will fail in normal use? Probably not, but we had one fail on us when a spare alternator slid across a shelf and hit the in-board end of the assembly so it can/could potentially happen.

My point here is that when buying a boat with this type of installation please be aware of and know that it is, and can be, a potential week point that may not meet the minimum ABYC safety standards for seacocks and thru-hull fittings, at least in the 3/4" size range..

other sizes: small medium large
previous | next
comment | share