photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Ed Knepley | all galleries >> Photo a Day (PAD) since 5/04 >> oct_08_pad > 10/18/08 - Blue Ridge Autumn
previous | next
10/18/08 - Blue Ridge Autumn

10/18/08 - Blue Ridge Autumn

Buck Hollow Overlook - usually my second stop when coming into Shenandoah National Park at Thornton Gap. The tree, rock, flowers of the season (or ivy in this case), ridges receding into the distance, and the sky/atmosphere of the day usually tell a different story every time that I stop. This is an overcast autumn-day story.
This was taken with a 3-stop grad neutral density filter & circular polarizer to control the tonal contrast and pop the sky/colors a bit. Since I have been experimenting with HDR, I also did a 3-exposure (-2, 0, +2) HDR for comparison (there is none IMO). - - The conventional is better unless you prefer the HDR artificiality - in this case halos which, with some work, I suspect that I could have reduced. The HDR definitely shows more detail - check the tree trunk and the farthest ridge for example - but personally I prefer this non-HDR with subdued detail (but have been told that's mainly because that's how we've become used to seeing photos, but I don't really care because the subdued detail helps call attention to the elements I want you to most see - the rock, the lower trunk/ivy and the 1st ridge - three points to move your eye through without too much distraction from the rest of the image which is just supplying context).
To me the bottom line regarding HDR is - use it when the situation requires it OR if you're looking for the characteristic HDR "illustration/cartoon" appearance - otherwise leave it alone. There is absolutely NO need for HDR on a shot like this, but some "name" pros are going there regardless (that's where the commercial book/workshop/endorsement money is, I guess). For an example where HDR was needed (but I tried to keep the result *natural*) see -

Nikon D300
1/2s f/22.0 at 18.0mm iso200 full exif

other sizes: small medium original
comment | share
Naomi Sheaffer04-Nov-2008 00:40
I like the way you framed this shot with the tree and ivy. Brilliant! V
Tom Briggs20-Oct-2008 19:00
Fabulous, Ed ... could be a painting ... beautifully seen and done ... voted
Jola Dziubinska18-Oct-2008 13:14
I'm in love with Blue Ridge Mts, especially in Fall. Fabulous image, love this compo a lot. Vote.
Larry Peterson18-Oct-2008 13:08
Great capture, Ed. Very well composed. Very well done. V